Blog

Which statement is true regarding the UDP client process during a session with a server?

• Application servers have to use port numbers above 1024 in order to be UDP capable.
• A three-way handshake takes place before the transmission of data begins.
• A session must be established before datagrams can be exchanged.
• Datagrams that arrive in a different order than that in which they were sent are not placed in order.

The correct answer is:

“Datagrams that arrive in a different order than that in which they were sent are not placed in order.”

Let’s examine why this is the correct answer in detail, as well as why the other statements are incorrect.

Understanding UDP: The User Datagram Protocol

UDP, or User Datagram Protocol, is one of the core protocols in the Internet Protocol (IP) suite, often used for tasks that require speed and efficiency rather than guaranteed delivery. Unlike TCP (Transmission Control Protocol), which prioritizes reliable data transfer with error-checking, acknowledgment, and data sequence reordering, UDP operates with minimal overhead. UDP is considered a “connectionless” protocol because it doesn’t establish a persistent connection between sender and receiver before data transfer occurs.

This lack of connection establishment and simplified data transfer process makes UDP very fast. However, it also means that UDP doesn’t have built-in features to handle packet reordering, retransmissions, or acknowledgment of received data.

Why “Datagrams that arrive in a different order than that in which they were sent are not placed in order” is Correct

1. No Sequencing Mechanism: UDP does not track packet order, meaning it lacks the sequencing mechanism that TCP uses. In TCP, each packet is given a sequence number, and the receiving device can reorder packets based on these sequence numbers if they arrive out of order. UDP, however, sends packets independently without such numbering, so if they arrive in a different order, the receiving application layer will get them as-is.
2. Non-Reliable Delivery: Since UDP is designed for applications that can tolerate data loss and out-of-order packets, it doesn’t provide any correction mechanism. Applications that use UDP are responsible for managing order if they require it. For instance, media streaming protocols often use UDP, as they can manage minor packet loss or out-of-order packets without significant issues.
3. Low Latency Requirement: UDP’s lack of sequencing and error-checking features makes it much faster than TCP, which is crucial for latency-sensitive applications. For example, online gaming, VoIP (Voice over IP), and video conferencing commonly use UDP because they prioritize real-time data transmission over perfect accuracy. If some packets arrive late or out of order, they are either ignored or used as they are without rearrangement.
4. Datagram Nature: UDP treats each packet (or datagram) as a standalone unit. When a datagram is sent, it reaches the destination independently of any other datagrams. There’s no concept of maintaining a flow or order. This is inherently different from TCP, where the protocol tries to ensure that all segments (TCP’s version of packets) arrive in order.

Why the Other Statements are Incorrect

1. “Application servers have to use port numbers above 1024 in order to be UDP capable.”
   • This statement is false because port numbers don’t dictate whether a service is UDP-capable or not. Instead, a port number simply provides a way to identify specific processes or services on a device.
   • Port numbers are divided into ranges, such as well-known ports (0-1023) for standard services (like HTTP on port 80 or DNS on port 53) and dynamic/private ports (above 1024). However, any port can be used for either TCP or UDP depending on how the server is configured.
   • In fact, some essential UDP services, like DNS (Domain Name System), use well-known ports under 1024 (port 53 in DNS’s case).
2. “A three-way handshake takes place before the transmission of data begins.”
   • This is a feature specific to TCP, not UDP. The TCP three-way handshake (SYN, SYN-ACK, ACK) establishes a connection between the client and server before data transmission starts. This connection-oriented approach ensures that both parties are ready to communicate and can guarantee reliable data transfer.
   • UDP is a connectionless protocol and, as such, doesn’t perform a handshake or require connection establishment. A client using UDP simply sends datagrams to the server, and the server receives them if it’s ready to do so. This absence of a handshake contributes to UDP’s speed but also to its lack of reliability compared to TCP.
3. “A session must be established before datagrams can be exchanged.”
   • Again, this is true for TCP but not for UDP. UDP is stateless, meaning there’s no concept of a “session” as there is with TCP. In UDP, the sender transmits datagrams to a specified IP and port without setting up a formal connection.
   • This makes UDP ideal for applications that need quick and stateless communication, as no persistent session or connection management overhead is required. Once the datagrams are sent, they are either received or not, and the client or server doesn’t keep any record of the communication session.

Real-World Applications of UDP and How They Handle Packet Order

While UDP does not inherently reorder packets, applications can implement their mechanisms to deal with out-of-order packets if needed. Here’s how some UDP-based applications deal with this issue:

1. Streaming Media: In applications like video or audio streaming, the software can tolerate a certain amount of packet loss or out-of-order delivery. Instead of relying on reordering, these applications play the media as it arrives, maintaining a smooth experience despite minor disruptions.
2. Online Gaming: Multiplayer games often prioritize speed over accuracy, as they require real-time updates. If a player’s movement packets arrive out of order, the game software may use the latest position data and ignore the earlier packets, rather than reordering them.
3. DNS (Domain Name System): DNS queries are sent using UDP because they are typically very short requests that require a quick response. If a DNS request or response arrives late, the client will generally resend the request rather than attempt to reorder anything.

In conclusion, the correct statement that “Datagrams that arrive in a different order than that in which they were sent are not placed in order” is an accurate description of UDP’s behavior. This characteristic of UDP reflects its design goals, offering a fast, connectionless, and low-latency protocol at the expense of reliability and packet order.